GMP Bench
← Back to Test Cases

Create Batch Manufacturing Record for Metformin Tablets

Task CompletionBatch Recordhard
System Prompt
You are a pharmaceutical manufacturing documentation specialist with deep
expertise in GMP-compliant batch manufacturing records. You create documents
that meet the requirements of 21 CFR 211.186-188, EU GMP Annex 15, and
ICH Q7 documentation standards. Your outputs must be precise, complete,
and suitable for use in a regulated manufacturing environment.
User Prompt
Create a batch manufacturing record (BMR) template for the manufacture of
"Metformin HCl 500 mg Film-Coated Tablets" using a wet granulation process.

Product context:
- Product: Metformin Hydrochloride Tablets, 500 mg
- Batch size: 300 kg (approximately 600,000 tablets)
- Dosage form: Film-coated tablets
- Manufacturing process: Wet granulation, drying, milling, blending,
  compression, film coating
- Key excipients: Povidone (binder), Magnesium Stearate (lubricant),
  Hypromellose (film coat), Microcrystalline Cellulose (filler)

The BMR should include all sections required by GMP regulations including:
header information, bill of materials, equipment list, step-by-step
manufacturing instructions with in-process controls, critical process
parameters with acceptance criteria, yield calculations, sampling
instructions, deviation/comments sections, and sign-off lines.

Ensure each manufacturing step includes spaces for recording actual
parameters, operator initials, verification signatures, dates/times,
and any deviations observed.
Rubric
DimensionWeightCriteria
GMP Compliance25%The BMR must comply with 21 CFR 211.186/188 and EU GMP Chapter 4. It should include: product identification (name, strength, dosage form, batch number, batch size), complete bill of materials with specific quantities and reference standards, equipment identification fields, signature and date lines for each critical step, deviation recording sections, and reconciliation of materials. Header must include document control fields (version, effective date, page numbering).
Technical Accuracy25%The wet granulation process must be technically sound and reflect real-world pharmaceutical manufacturing. Process parameters should be realistic: granulation endpoint parameters (amperage, torque, or visual), drying LOD targets (typically 1-3% for metformin), compression parameters (hardness, thickness, friability, weight variation), coating parameters (inlet/exhaust temperature, spray rate, pan speed). Equipment types should be appropriate (high-shear granulator, fluid bed dryer, rotary tablet press, coating pan). The process flow must be logical and sequential.
Completeness20%The BMR must cover all manufacturing stages: dispensing/weighing, granulation (dry mix, binder preparation, wet granulation), drying, milling/sizing, lubrication/final blend, compression, film coating, and bulk packaging/transfer. Each stage should include in-process controls with acceptance criteria, sampling instructions with quantities and methods, yield calculations (theoretical vs actual), and environmental condition requirements where applicable. Line clearance checklists should be present for each major stage.
Usability15%The BMR should be clearly organized and practical for shopfloor use. Instructions should be unambiguous and written in imperative form. Tables should be used for recording parameters. Blank spaces or fields should be clearly indicated for data entry. The document should have logical flow with clear section numbering. Calculations should include formulas with spaces for actual values. Warning statements or notes should highlight critical steps or safety considerations.
Data Integrity15%The BMR must support ALCOA+ data integrity principles (Attributable, Legible, Contemporaneous, Original, Accurate, Complete, Consistent, Enduring, Available). Every data entry point should have corresponding fields for performer identity, date/time, and verification signature. Correction procedures should be referenced. Calculations should be independently verifiable. Sequential pagination should be indicated. Provisions for recording deviations at each step should be included.
Source Materials
  • 0
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3

Cross-Model Comparison

ModelScoreLatencyTokens InTokens Out
Qwen3.8 Max (2.4T-A95B)N/AN/A--
Qwen3.8-FlashN/AN/A--
Qwen3.8-FlashN/AN/A--
GLM-5.3N/AN/A--
GLM-5.3N/AN/A--
Muse Glimmer 30BN/AN/A--
Muse Glimmer 30BN/AN/A--
Muse Glimmer 30BN/AN/A--
GLM-5.3N/AN/A--
MiniMax M3N/AN/A--
MiniMax M3N/AN/A--
Qwen3.8-FlashN/AN/A--
Hy4 PreviewN/AN/A--
Qwen3.8 Max (2.4T-A95B)N/AN/A--
MiniMax M3N/AN/A--
Qwen3.8-FlashN/A374.6s56048,000
Hy4 PreviewN/AN/A--
Qwen3.8 Max (2.4T-A95B)N/AN/A--
Hy4 PreviewN/AN/A--
Claude Opus 593.0%439.4s78639,686
GPT-5.491.5%83.6s4617,148
Claude Opus 591.2%422.0s78636,407
GLM-5.3-Flash91.0%556.6s47623,110
Claude Opus 590.8%498.0s78642,541
Kimi K390.7%700.4s55919,513
GLM-5.3-Flash90.6%478.0s47621,545
Kimi K390.6%517.4s55915,674
Qwen3.5-397B-A17B90.5%47.6s5225,631
GPT-5.4 mini90.5%24.3s4615,254
Hy4 Preview89.6%287.3s48523,378
GLM-5.389.3%265.8s47629,316
Qwen3.8 Max (2.4T-A95B)89.1%633.7s56028,824
Kimi K388.8%669.0s56218,833
Claude Sonnet 588.8%97.5s78610,325
DeepSeek-V3.288.5%109.5s4724,248
Mistral Large 3 675B88.5%101.5s5046,472
DeepSeek-R188.5%117.4s4724,550
MiniMax M2.788.4%109.4s46314,612
Hy4 Preview88.3%263.9s48521,512
Hy4 Preview88.2%249.4s48521,138
GPT-5.6 Terra86.8%137.2s4618,924
GPT-5.6 Terra86.8%142.4s46112,582
GPT-5.6 Luna86.6%80.8s4618,813
Qwen3.8-Flash86.4%208.6s56027,129
GPT-5.6 Sol86.4%129.9s46110,507
Claude Sonnet 586.3%87.7s78610,002
MiniMax M386.2%57.2s61710,802
Qwen3.8 Max (2.4T-A95B)86.2%700.6s56031,143
Qwen3.5-35B-A3B86.1%43.4s5236,107
Claude Haiku 4.586.0%89.7s54914,977
MiniMax M385.8%123.8s61710,408
Qwen3.6 35B A3B85.7%32.0s5226,738
Qwen3.6 27B85.5%171.9s5226,301
Claude Opus 4.885.4%74.7s7866,939
GPT-5.6 Luna85.3%71.8s4617,966
GPT-5.4 nano85.0%29.5s4616,076
GLM-5.384.8%43.7s4775,673
DeepSeek V4 Pro84.5%159.7s4729,837
Qwen3.6 27B84.4%239.3s5228,267
DeepSeek V4 Pro84.3%241.2s4728,271
Qwen3.6 27B84.3%89.8s5228,218
Claude Opus 4.684.3%199.0s55016,000
MiniMax M383.9%62.9s5659,456
GPT-5.6 Luna83.9%86.2s4618,968
GLM-5.3-Flash83.8%529.7s47622,889
GLM-5.283.7%223.4s47614,787
Qwen3.6 27B83.7%106.1s5226,958
Qwen3.8 27B83.5%423.2s56028,534
Qwen3.6 35B A3B83.3%45.4s5228,511
Claude Sonnet 583.3%86.5s7869,741
GLM-5.283.0%187.9s47612,630
Qwen3.8 27B82.8%519.5s56030,017
GPT-5.6 Sol82.8%144.0s46112,957
Gemini 3.1 Pro82.5%75.7s4985,228
DeepSeek V4 Pro82.3%191.7s4726,257
Qwen3.8 Max (2.4T-A95B)81.3%157.5s56035,043
GLM-5.381.3%59.8s4778,250
Qwen3.6 35B A3B81.3%49.3s5227,390
Qwen3.8-Flash81.0%319.8s56038,647
GPT-5.6 Sol80.6%149.9s46113,315
DeepSeek V4 Flash80.3%50.5s4725,917
GPT-5.6 Terra79.4%99.9s4618,681
GLM-5.279.3%50.7s4704,186
Qwen3.8-Flash79.0%246.8s56028,695
Qwen3.5-397B-A17B78.8%86.5s5225,870
Qwen3.5-397B-A17B78.5%76.2s5225,653
Claude Sonnet 4.678.5%137.8s55016,000
MiniMax M2.778.3%119.1s46112,157
Mistral Small 260378.1%15.2s5163,174
Qwen3.6 35B A3B78.0%85.4s5227,337
Qwen3.8 27B77.8%379.9s56022,590
DeepSeek V4 Flash77.0%69.9s4725,057
DeepSeek-V3.275.5%151.4s4724,315
DeepSeek V4 Pro75.0%120.9s4727,205
DeepSeek-V3.274.6%137.7s4723,953
DeepSeek-V3.274.5%106.0s4723,890
MiniMax M2.774.3%145.4s46114,271
Qwen3.5-397B-A17B73.9%648.3s5226,713
DeepSeek-R172.9%269.7s4714,662
Muse Glimmer 30B72.5%53.5s4823,447
MiniMax M2.772.1%127.6s46112,786
Muse Glimmer 30B71.1%55.5s4823,648
DeepSeek-V3.270.9%135.1s4723,918
DeepSeek V4 Flash70.5%217.8s4727,930
Claude Haiku 4.570.5%74.3s54913,652
Claude Haiku 4.570.2%90.9s54916,208
GLM-5.269.2%82.3s4764,272
Mistral Large 3 675B69.2%56.3s5045,328
Gemma 4 31B IT68.8%76.8s5322,024
Gemma 4 31B IT68.3%57.5s5151,952
Muse Glimmer 30B68.0%65.4s4824,205
Mistral Large 3 675B67.7%52.7s5044,621
Llama 4 Maverick67.6%88.4s4691,692
Gemini 3 Flash67.5%14.2s4982,134
DeepSeek V4 Flash67.3%44.2s4724,718
Gemma 4 26B A4B IT67.2%47.1s5161,904
Mistral Small 260364.5%39.7s5165,009
Gemma 4 31B IT63.7%68.0s5152,121
Gemma 4 26B A4B IT63.4%29.9s5151,976
Gemma 4 31B IT63.2%74.4s5152,196
Mistral Large 3 675B63.0%41.6s5043,764
Mistral Small 260362.5%23.8s5164,143
Qwen3.5-35B-A3B62.0%30.7s5224,213
Qwen3.5-35B-A3B60.0%67.1s5229,125
Claude Haiku 4.559.5%97.6s54916,637
DeepSeek-R159.5%117.0s4711,987
DeepSeek-R158.8%114.7s4732,199
Gemma 4 26B A4B IT58.8%40.4s5162,572
Mistral Small 260357.8%21.6s5163,681
Qwen3.5-35B-A3B56.5%73.3s5228,530
Gemma 4 26B A4B IT54.5%37.5s5151,905
Llama 4 Maverick52.0%102.2s4691,640
Llama 3.3 70B Instruct51.5%38.4s4791,289
Llama 3.3 70B Instruct49.5%22.0s4791,170
DeepSeek-R1-Distill-Qwen-32B45.3%174.1s4951,720
Llama 3.3 70B Instruct45.0%34.6s4981,208
Llama 4 Maverick44.3%33.4s4691,679
Llama 4 Scout43.8%16.9s4691,202
Gemini 3.1 Flash-Lite42.5%4.6s5001,043
Llama 4 Scout42.3%41.5s4691,034
Llama 3.3 70B Instruct42.3%17.6s4791,220
Llama 4 Scout40.8%39.5s469992
Llama 4 Scout36.0%46.1s4691,114
Llama 4 Maverick20.3%34.3s581519

Tags

batch_recordtablet_manufacturingwet_granulationdocumentation